An Indiana mother sought to change custody of her three children and access their father’s mental-health records; an appeals court rejected her bid, upheld $18,500 in legal fees and ordered her to pay more


An Indiana mother sought to change custody of her three children and access their father's mental-health records; an appeals court rejected her bid, upheld $18,500 in legal fees and ordered her to pay more

An Indiana mother who tried to regain sole legal custody of her three children from her former husband and gain access to his mental-health records has lost her appeal. She must also pay more of his legal costs. In a ruling issued on 16 November 2026, the Indiana Court of Appeals rejected all the challenges brought by Sember Darland-Chappell against her former husband, Andrew Hahn. A three-judge panel upheld a Hamilton Superior Court order that denied her request to change custody, refused to let her see Hahn’s therapy notes and ordered her to pay $18,500 towards his trial lawyer’s fees. The appeals court also approved Hahn’s request for appellate legal fees and sent the case back to the trial court to decide how much more she must pay. Judge Cale Bradford wrote the decision. Judges Patricia Riley Bailey and Elaine Brown Altice agreed with the ruling.

Seven years of court battles

Darland-Chappell and Hahn divorced on 19 February 2020, according to the Indiana Court of Appeals decision. Under their original divorce order, the former couple shared legal custody of their three children, who were born in October 2009, June 2011 and October 2013. However, Darland-Chappell had primary physical custody. Hahn had regular parenting time with the children on Wednesday evenings and every other weekend. The dispute grew in June 2021 when Hahn asked the court to change legal custody and parenting time. Darland-Chappell filed a request of her own and asked the court to arrange a formal child custody evaluation. Clinical psychologist Dr Bart Ferraro carried out the evaluation between February and May 2022. He prepared a 131-page report.The trial court relied heavily on Dr Ferraro’s recommendations. On 16 May 2023, it gave Hahn sole legal custody and changed the physical parenting schedule so that the children would spend alternating full weeks with each parent. Darland-Chappell filed a request to regain custody in November 2023. The trial court rejected it in May 2024 after holding a three-day hearing. On 2 January 2025, she filed another request to change custody, along with a motion asking for a different judge. In her filing, Darland-Chappell claimed Hahn “has weaponized his sole legal custody status and has seemed to be more focused on lording that over [Mother], rather than on making sound decisions for the [C]hildren.” She also argued that alternating weeks with each parent “provides no consistency or continuity for the [C]hildren.”

Fight over therapy records and guardian ad litem

After a new judge took over the case, Darland-Chappell filed several requests before the custody hearing. In late January 2025, she asked the court to appoint a guardian ad litem, an independent person who looks after children’s interests in court cases. She argued that a new evaluation was needed because Dr Ferraro’s report was almost three years old. Hahn opposed the request. He pointed out that the children had been regularly seeing a therapist since 2020. The trial court rejected her request in March 2025. Darland-Chappell also asked the judge to speak privately with all three children. She also issued a subpoena for records held by Vanessa McCaskey, the family therapist who worked with Hahn and the children. When McCaskey asked the court to cancel the subpoena, Darland-Chappell filed a request in July 2025 to force the release of Hahn’s mental-health records under Indiana Code section 16-39-3-3.Both Hahn and McCaskey told the court that releasing the records could harm the therapy process. McCaskey said Hahn might stop speaking openly during sessions if he thought his words could be given to his former wife. She warned that this could damage the work he was doing to improve his relationship with the children. Hahn also told the court that Darland-Chappell’s earlier involvement with another family therapist, Angela Hardy, had seriously disrupted counselling. The children’s individual therapist, Dr Natasha Anderson, had then recommended finding a new therapist.On 8 September 2025, the trial court rejected Darland-Chappell’s request for Hahn’s records. The judge decided that the possible harm to Hahn as a patient was greater than the need to share the records. The judge explained that court-ordered counselling was meant to help the children adjust and improve their relationship with their father. This followed an earlier warning from the court that therapy was not ordered “to give either party the opportunity to reload their quivers with arrows to sling at the other party in the next hearing.“

Trial court findings and appellate ruling

Shortly before the main hearing started, Darland-Chappell filed another request on 20 October 2025. She wanted to change the summer parenting schedule. She claimed that she had less freedom than Hahn to plan quality time with the children, partly because of their travel baseball commitments. The Hamilton Superior Court held hearings over three days in October and December 2025. After hearing the evidence, it rejected all of Darland-Chappell’s requests and refused to interview the children privately.In its written decision, the trial court found that there had been no major and ongoing change in circumstances since May 2024 that would justify changing custody or the summer schedule. The judge said that approving Darland-Chappell’s request “would legalize and institutionalize the very behaviors exhibited by Mother — alienating the [C]hildren from Father and minimizing his role in their lives — which Dr. Ferraro warned the Court against in his extensive [CCE].” The court also said Darland-Chappell had shown little willingness to change her behaviour. The judge believed that making changes would help the children by bringing an end to “the constant onslaught of litigation that has occurred for the past [seven] years.”Along with rejecting her custody requests, the trial court ordered Darland-Chappell to pay $18,500 towards Hahn’s legal costs. Darland-Chappell appealed the decision. She argued that the trial court had made several mistakes by refusing to appoint a guardian ad litem, declining to speak privately with the children, blocking access to Hahn’s therapy records, rejecting her request to change custody and ordering her to pay $18,500 in legal fees. The Indiana Court of Appeals rejected all her arguments. It found that the trial court had acted within its legal powers and had based its decisions on the extensive evidence and earlier clinical evaluations. The appeals court also ruled in Hahn’s favour on his request for appellate attorney fees. The case will now return to Hamilton Superior Court, where the judge will work out the additional amount Darland-Chappell must pay for Hahn’s legal costs during the appeal.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *